Bay Area Skeptics

The San Francisco Bay Area's skeptical organization since 1982

Bay Area Skeptics and Religion

From time to time, Bay Area Skeptics board members are asked about BAS’s position on religion. We have a brief mission statement that explains our policy of religious neutrality, but like all such statements, from time to time one must consider whether it is communicating fully the organization’s perspective. You can read it at

In recent correspondence with a friend about the topic of skepticism and atheism, I wrote the following, which, although not an official BAS statement, reflects what most (though not all) of the BAS officers have thought over the years. For what it’s worth — here are some additional thoughts on the matter:

Dear _____,

People on my side of the issue want skepticism to be about appreciation and enjoyment of science, and critical thinking, which of course is not philosophy-specific. After all, if your concern is showing people scientifically why homeopathy is quackery, religion isn’t an issue. And skeptics are more concerned with things like homeopathy than with the meaning of life. This doesn’t prohibit us from evaluating/criticizing fact claims made in the name of religion if such claims are shown to be wrong through science. We can show through science why the catastrophic cutting of Grand Canyon by a Flood is wrong, and do. On the other hand, if science is about explaining through natural causes, it’s not a scientific question whether God miraculously raised Jesus from the dead.

The distinction also has to do with one’s definition of science, and whether that definition includes philosophical as well as methodological naturalism. Mine doesn’t. We don’t want to say “sorry, you can’t be a critical thinker and enjoy science unless you are a nonbeliever” because that is poor philosophy of science, and additionally would unnecessarily truncate our movement.

So BAS is an “old fashioned” skeptical organization that is religiously-neutral. Most people have more than one identity: I’ll wear my humanist hat in some circles, but not at the bee-keeper’s meeting. One can also be a BAS member and not have to wear an atheist hat to do so.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *