Bay Area Skeptics

The San Francisco Bay Area's skeptical organization since 1982

SciSchmooze Meets ChatGPT

Venus-Jupiter conjunction, courtesy Dr. Alex Filippenko

Welcome to our weekly science newsletter! In this newsletter, we aim to bring you the latest and most interesting developments in the world of science in a way that is accessible and engaging for general audiences.

Whether you’re a science enthusiast or just looking to stay informed about the latest discoveries and innovations, we’ve got you covered. Each week, we’ll explore a variety of topics including astronomy, biology, chemistry, physics, and more.

Our team of expert science writers will break down complex concepts into easy-to-understand explanations, providing you with a deeper understanding of the world around us. We’ll also feature interviews with scientists, highlight interesting research studies, and share fun science facts and trivia.

We hope that our newsletter will inspire you to stay curious and excited about the wonders of science. So sit back, relax, and enjoy your weekly dose of science news!

The preceding introduction was written by ChatGPT, the Artificial Intelligence engine you’ve probably heard a lot about. Today we’ll have a conversation with it, as well as link to some articles written about it.

While the third paragraph sounds nice, your editors (Herb, David, and myself) are not experts, nor do we often do interviews. But this is a pretty good response to the directions I gave to ChatGPT, namely “Write an introduction to a weekly science newsletter for general audiences”.

Next I told it to “Include references to current discoveries”. Here’s the response:

Absolutely! Here are a few references to some current discoveries that we might include in our weekly science newsletter.

  • In astronomy, scientists recently announced the discovery of a new exoplanet, dubbed TOI-1231 b, that has the potential to support life. This planet is located relatively close to Earth, making it an exciting target for future studies.
  • Biologists have made progress in understanding the cellular mechanisms behind aging. A recent study identified a protein that is linked to age-related decline in muscle stem cells, which could help pave the way for new anti-aging treatments.
  • In physics, researchers at CERN’s Large Hadron Collider have discovered a new particle called the “Xicc++”, which contains two charm quarks and one up quark. This discovery could provide new insights into the fundamental nature of matter.
  • Chemists have developed a new technique for producing hydrogen fuel using sunlight and seawater. This could provide a sustainable and abundant source of clean energy for the future.

By keeping up with these exciting discoveries and more, we hope to provide our readers with a glimpse into the cutting-edge research that is shaping our understanding of the world around us.

I then went online to do a little research on these current discoveries. It turns out ChatGPT’s knowledge ends in 2021. It has not been given data newer than that, hence the reference below to the upcoming James Webb Space Telescope which has been in space for over a year now. I looked up TOI-1231 b as that seemed like an easy one to find information about. I asked ChatGPT to “tell me more atout [sic] TOI-1231 b”. Of note, I did accidently make a typo, meaning to say “about” but ChatGPT figured that out.

Sure! TOI-1231 b is a newly discovered exoplanet that is located approximately 90 light-years away from Earth in the constellation of Dorado. The planet was first identified by NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) and was confirmed using ground-based telescopes.

TOI-1231 b is what’s known as a “super-Earth” because it is slightly larger than Earth, with a radius about 1.4 times that of our planet. The planet orbits a red dwarf star, which is smaller and cooler than our Sun, in a relatively tight orbit that takes just 24 days to complete.

One of the most exciting things about TOI-1231 b is that it is located in what is known as the “habitable zone” of its star, which is the range of distances where conditions could be right for liquid water to exist on the planet’s surface. This means that TOI-1231 b could potentially support life, although we don’t yet have enough information to know for sure.

Scientists are planning to use future telescopes, such as NASA’s upcoming James Webb Space Telescope, to study the atmosphere of TOI-1231 b in more detail. By analyzing the composition of the planet’s atmosphere, they hope to learn more about its potential habitability and the types of molecules that are present on the surface.

The discovery of TOI-1231 b is an exciting step forward in the search for potentially habitable exoplanets and could help us to better understand the conditions necessary for life to exist beyond our own Solar System.

Now things get interesting. TOI-1231 b is not a super earth, but a Neptune-sized planet. I mistakenly found a link to TOI-1331 in my Google search results, didn’t notice the error, and provided the following feedback to ChatGPT: “TOI-1231 b is not a super earth. It is classified as a Neptune-sized planet and it orbits a binary star pair”, which would be TOI-1331, not TOI-1321. ChatGPT corrected itself, but didn’t catch my error.

I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. You are correct that TOI-1231 b is not a super-Earth, but rather a Neptune-sized exoplanet, and it orbits a binary star pair.

The planet has a radius of approximately 2.7 times that of Earth, which makes it larger than the Earth, but smaller than the gas giant Neptune in our Solar System. It was first identified by NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) in 2019, and its size and mass were later confirmed using ground-based telescopes.

TOI-1231 b orbits a pair of M dwarf stars that are about one-third the size and mass of the Sun, and it takes approximately 24 Earth days to complete one orbit. The planet’s surface temperature is estimated to be around 134 degrees Celsius (273 degrees Fahrenheit), which is relatively cool for a planet that is located in the habitable zone of its star.

The discovery of TOI-1231 b is still an exciting development in the search for potentially habitable exoplanets, as its location in the habitable zone suggests that it could have the right conditions for liquid water to exist on its surface. Future observations using telescopes like the James Webb Space Telescope may reveal more about the planet’s atmosphere and composition, which could provide further insights into its potential habitability.

TOI-1231 is, in fact, a single M dwarf star, but the rest of the information appears to be correct. So I corrected myself: “The information I gave you about the star is incorrect. It is not a binary pair”.

I apologize again for the confusion in my previous responses. You are correct that TOI-1231 b orbits a single star, not a binary pair.

The host star of TOI-1231 b is an M dwarf star, which is a type of small, cool, and dim star. The star is about one-fifth the size of the Sun and is located approximately 90 light-years away from Earth in the constellation of Dorado.

As I mentioned earlier, TOI-1231 b is a Neptune-sized exoplanet that was first discovered by NASA’s TESS in 2019. The planet is located in the habitable zone of its star, which means that it orbits at a distance where temperatures are just right for liquid water to exist on its surface.

There is a lot of bad information on the internet. Some of it is outdated, some simply false. Unless the folks feeding engines such as ChatGPT have verified the information they provide as valid and current, the engine itself has no way to verify the data it uses for answers. The old computer adage of “garbage in, garbage out” applies. A little more alarming is the fact that I provided incorrect information to the engine, and it didn’t correct me. The writing style it uses is very impressive, but it can make incorrect information sound very authoritative.

Here’s a more in depth article about the capabilities and limits of ChatGPT, echoing my experience. Tom Scott, a British YouTuber who produces STEM education, had this to say about his experiences using ChatGPT to try and solve a simple email problem and some more existential issues with AI. How good is ChatGPT with physics questions? How are we preparing today’s students to deal with AI such as ChatGPT? In New York, some computer science courses are addressing this.

I have to agree with Tom Scott that we are on the edge of a huge leap in technology that will change the world, for better or worse. This is a topic that bears watching.

Moving on to earthquakes. An unusually strong aftershock struck Turkey this week. We can’t predict earthquakes, but we can forecast them. Social media (a phrase I’m starting to hate) was full of misinformation following the quakes. How do we counter bad information about science? A Nobel Prize Summit aims to address this issue this May.

We live in an age of incredible discovery, yet so many mysteries remain, such as this Dark Galaxy that emits no visible light!

Are black holes the source of dark energy? Perhaps! How about intermediate mass black holes?

The auroras found in our most northern and southern latitudes are beautiful and mysterious. New ones have been discovered in the skies of Jupiter’s moons!

Alex Filippenko sends along this bit of information about the conjunction of Venus and Jupiter in the evening sky.

“Venus is the brightest celestial object in the sky, other than the Sun and Moon (and occasionally a bright meteor). It is now visible in the west/southwest evening sky shortly after sunset. Jupiter, usually the second-brightest object (Mars sometimes appears brighter, but not often), is also visible in the west/southwest shortly after sunset (45 minutes to an hour after sunset is a good time to look).

”[T]he two planets will approach each other in the sky, coming closest together (sometimes called a “conjunction”) on March 1 and 2 when they will form a lovely close pair. You might want to take some photos with your smartphone or regular camera!

“The waxing Moon will appear progressively farther above Jupiter, so not as striking. But Venus and Jupiter will continue to approach each other until conjunction on March 1 and 2. Try to view them at least those evenings and a few earlier and later dates! Thereafter, the two planets will drift progressively further apart as Venus continues to get farther from the Sun (in the sky) while Jupiter approaches the Sun.

”This ‘dance of the bright planets’ during the next two weeks will dramatically show that planets drift slowly among the backdrop of ‘fixed stars’ in the sky. (Indeed, the word ‘planet’ goes back to ancient Greek, meaning ‘wanderer’ — the behavior of planets differs from that of the stars, whose positions relative to each other don’t visibly change from night to night.)”

Alex will be speaking on early results from the James Webb Space Telescope on March 8 at the Silicon Valley Astronomy Lecture at Foothill College. I heard him give a version of this talk recently and it was excellent. Details here.

News from the animal kingdom:

California’s ongoing drought costs a lot in both money and nature. Last year, the state lost 36 million trees as a result of the drought.

This week marked the one year anniversary of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This war has awful ecological, economic and human consequences in Ukraine. It is also the first one where commercial space-based technologies have been used with regularity, proving, or disproving claims by both sides and documenting the destruction.

It is difficult for those of us living thousands of miles away to really understand just what is happening in Ukraine. As I have a close friend who lived there, I have a better idea, but still can’t fully comprehend the experience, the loss, and the fear.

May be an image of nature
Sunflowers are the national flower of Ukraine. Credit: Gillian Claus, via Facebook. We first published this picture one year ago.

Have a great week in Science!

Upcoming Events:
Click to see the next two weeks of events in your browser.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *